Skip to content

Create a supported testing release for power-users

Debian's recommendation against users running testing (due to a lack of security support) means we don't have a reasonable answer for desktop users who want to run reasonably current software.

This hurts Debian's credibility among power-users and probably deprives us of a developer pool that are interested in helping to maintain desktop environments and the experience around them.

Running testing instead of unstable has advantages: It protects users from a large number of developer mistakes, transitions, and other archive inconsistency. There are also disadvantages: Packages in use may be dropped from testing, and security updates may be held-up by transitions.

I see two potential ways out of this:

  1. Make unstable more useable.
    • By gating all uploads through another queue that then migrate to unstable ASAP (like Ubuntu's -proposed pocket)
  2. Make testing supportable.
    • Maybe by flagging up security issues caught in unstable, and have a team that helps shepherd them through (or upload to testing-proposed-updates, if necessary)
    • Probably: Document mixed testing/unstable, and maybe provide some tooling to help users running this. (e.g. pull security updates from unstable, when necessary)
To upload designs, you'll need to enable LFS and have an admin enable hashed storage. More information